EFY Times  
Thursday, October 08, 2015

Matthias Ettrich: The KDE-Man!
Home >> Infotech >> Interviews
Matthias Ettrich: The KDE-Man!  
Nobody in their right mind would choose Windows over GNU/Linux based on the desktop experience alone, says Matthias Ettrich.   
Rate this news:  (46 Votes)
Saturday, March 15, 2008 The KDE 4.0, the latest version of KDE desktop environment, was released recently. On this occasion, we reached out to the founder of KDE project, Matthias Ettrich who started the KDE project back in 1996. Almost 12 years down the line, he's now working at Trolltech, hacking Qt. Here is what the KDE-Man had to say...

kde,Windows,Mac,Linux Desktops,Matthias Ettrich,founder,KDE project

How did KDE begin?
ME: KDE's history started with a posting of mine in various Linux and X11-related newsgroups almost 12 years ago in October 1996. We quickly assembled 40 or so developers and started hacking together. Since then, the project has grown a lot, both in terms of contributors and in terms of users. And most certainly in terms of the number of applications and lines of source code.

The time was just right in 1996. Linux was popular enough that it had plenty of developers and users who were interested in graphical user interfaces, as opposed to the early console-only hackers, as Microsoft shocked the Free Software world with Windows 95. It may sound unbelievable, but back then, many hackers thought something like Windows 95 could never be matched with Free Software. How wrong they were!

How much time do you contribute to the development of KDE now?
ME: I haven't done specific KDE coding work in a while. Everything I have been doing goes into Qt. But since Qt is a part of KDE, or KDE a superset of Qt, I still consider myself a KDE programmer.

So, what is your role at Trolltech?
ME: Until this year, and during the entire Qt 4 development phase, I've been Trolltech's head of the Qt desktop development unit. As vice president, engineering, I've been a member of the management team, and I've also been a member of the board of directors. I didn't want to miss the fun and the experience I gained from that, but after all those years I wanted to move back to my home country. Since the summer of 2006, we've been building up a new development site in Berlin/Germany for Trolltech, so currently I'm general manager of a pure development office as well as a senior software engineer. My successor in Oslo (in the VP engineering role) is another guy from the KDE project: Lars Knoll, the creator of KHTML. So Trolltech will remain as KDE-friendly as ever.

Firefox, OpenOffice.org and many other FOSS tools are becoming popular on the 'Windows' platform. Where do you see KDE on Windows?
ME: When you say KDE, there're at least three of them: the development platform, the desktop and the set of applications built on top of that platform. You will always get the best KDE experience when using all three combined. Nevertheless, the KDE team did a tremendous job to ensure that not only the underlying Qt libraries, but also the additional KDE libraries and technologies were portable. This makes it possible to develop true KDE applications on MS Windows, and in return, to use KDE applications on MS Windows. For application developers, this means more potential users, which to some is an important motivational factor: now your friends can use your applications without having to install Linux first.

And more users mean more developers, since developers of free applications typically start as users. My hope is that Windows users will fall in love with some of the apps, and some will eventually join the development team. Keep in mind that the real strength of a Free Software project is the number of developers, not the number of users. If the setting is correct, users eventually become developers, but this isn't a given. Many things have to fit together to make this happen. Last but not least, you need a friendly and helpful community and a powerful framework with a not-to-steep learning curve. KDE is very strong in both, so we are looking ahead to a very bright future.

Vista seems to be Microsoft's swan song. Do you think it is the right time for FOSS to hit hard and take over the market?
ME: The desktop problem has been solved many years ago. I mean, try to compare Windows XP with KDE 3: nobody in their right mind would choose Windows over GNU/Linux based on the desktop experience alone. The Web problem has also been solved. Microsoft clearly lost the Web war -- they failed to enhance the Web in a proprietary way. What remains are some legal issues on the multimedia side that can be mostly worked around, the office documents formats issue and the flood of applications that only run on Windows, mostly games.

What we need to get across to the software developers is: write portable software -- it's easy, it's doable and it's feasible; simply use KDE/Qt or Java technologies. With Qt Jambi, you can even write KDE applications in Java. Microsoft Office is still a major hurdle; we need more governments and companies to have the bravery to standardise on truly open formats. A proprietary undocumented text format as the de facto standard -- and that's what .doc is -- is a shame for all parties involved. It's like using a special patented ink that can only be read with special patented sun glasses. Who would want to use that for all their scientific, private and business documents? Probably nobody. Why they do so with computers is beyond me.

How would you compare KDE 4 with Vista or Mac Leopard? In your opinion, which is the best and why?
ME: From a user's perspective, they play in the same league; so yes, you could do a feature-by-feature comparison. And, weighing certain features differently, different people will probably draw different conclusions on which one is the best. But that's mood.

To me personally, two things matter the most. First, how easy is it to develop applications that really utilise the power of the underlying platform? Keep in mind that those 'desktops' really are software development platforms, what you see on the screen is just the tip of the iceberg. And second, is it free, in the liberty sense of the word? Do I get the source code? Can I learn from it? Can I modify it? Can I share my modifications with others? Imagine where the world of computer science would be without Free Software! How much secret knowledge would be kept behind closed doors? Without us, people would study computer science and programming without ever having seen a real program in its entirety. That's like becoming writers without ever having read a complete book.

Many consider Plasma as the main highlight of KDE 4. Also, according to many, the new interface has taken a lot of design ideas from Mac. However, the UI team may have something else in mind. What were the major requirements proposed by the team?
ME: You don't need to go to the Mac to seek inspiration. KDE3 had SuperKaramba, which might have been inspired by Konfabulator, or not. The basic idea isn't all that new. There have always been small applet programs on X11 desktops -- the predecessors of today's desktop widgets. KDE's panel had them since Day 1. What's new to Plasma is the simplicity to create your own plasmoids. And that's not a Mac feature, but rather the fact that underlying technologies like SVG and scripting are ready and cry out loud to be used.

Despite Plasma and other assorted eye-candy, it's claimed that KDE 4 uses 40 per cent less memory compared to KDE 3. Is the claim valid? How did you achieve this, when the general trend is more features, and eye-candy requires more hardware power?
ME: There is typically no simple and straightforward fix when a program is slower than it should be, or uses more memory than it should be using. If there was a simple fix, it would have been done already. That's the power of Free Software. Anybody who cares enough can run a profiler and fix it. What we have done during Qt4 development was to carefully redesign many core aspects of Qt, with memory consumption and runtime behaviour in mind. The sum of all these thousands of changes ends up showing a significant effect.

I still would be very careful with claims that KDE 4 is going to be faster than 3. For the same features, it's probably true, but I fully trust the developers to find creative ways to spend the extra CPU cycles on new stuff. The performance part I care the most for is boot, log-in time, and application start-up time -- something we have already become quite good at.

Qt 4 is tagged as a major improvement over version 3. What are these improvements?
ME: Qt 3 came out in 2001, Qt 4.0 in 2005! We are now about to release Qt 4.4. Among the major improvements in the 4 series are: A new graphics system that makes modern SVG rendering possible. All the eye-candy with alpha blending, anti-aliasing, and gradients is possible because of this. Much stronger multi-threading support, so we can benefit from the multi-cores that have become common in the past few years. The speed and memory consumption issues we have already talked about. A set of new widgets with CSS styling capabilities. New tools, like our visual designer, assistant, IDE integrations, etc. It's open source across all platforms, including Mac OS X and MS Windows.

It contains a fast javascript scripting engine. Newer versions even include a multimedia API called Phonon, and a complete Web rendering widget based on Webkit. And with Jambi, Java developers can use it as well.

What follows the release of KDE 4? Any other major projects that you are working on currently?
ME: Apart from Qt 4.5 there's indeed another project. Unfortunately, I can't talk about it right now, but you will hopefully hear about it soon.

Do you have any plans to visit India? What do you want to say to the developer community in India?
ME: With a little daughter at home, I don't travel much at all these days. With regards to the development community in India, I think it's awesome to see the FOSS community getting stronger. India is a major commercial software development centre, home to some of the world's largest software companies, and there's no reason why it shouldn't play a similar role in the Free Software space. Remember: our biggest challenge in the short run is to get more cross-platform software, software that is portable and that also runs on free operating systems.

The technology is there; it's Qt and KDE, with either C++ or Java. Imagine some of the big Indian software development companies using their technology influence to push cross-platform solutions to their overseas clients. What a boost that would be for Free Software!

-- Swapnil Bhartiya

Swapnil Bhartiya, EFYTIMES News Network

Print Email Post Comment  (1)
(Total Views: )



Steve Terek   2759 days ago

Matthias asserts: "And more users mean more developers, since developers of free applications typically start as users. My hope is that Windows users will fall in love with some of the apps, and some will eventually join the development team. Keep in mind that the real strength of a Free Software project is the number of developers, not the number of users. If the setting is correct, users eventually become developers, but this isn't a given. Many things have to fit together to make this happen. Last but not least, you need a friendly and helpful community and a powerful framework with a not-to-steep learning curve. KDE is very strong in both, so we are looking ahead to a very bright future."

This, I think is a myopic view of PC users generally.

If Free Software takes this approach, and focuses its main effort in building its strength on the number of developers and not the number of users, then it will never threaten the market share of proprietary software vendors.

The overwhelming majority of PC users are PC users who do not ever want to be developers. They are hosewives, office workers, managers, writers, teachers, students, business managers, photographers, mathematicians, scientists, doctors, pilots, hunters, motor mechanics, painters, taxi drivers, hospital administrators, storemen, landscapers, artists, police officers ....

Since when does a builder want to go into the business of making trowels and spirit levels?! Or an artist into the business of making canvases?

What people want is to do what they like to do or need to do with the best possible tools available. If everybody was in the business of making tools, there'd be no-one doing all the other things that need to be done. I've never yet heard of a doctor making his own stethoscope, or an office administrator building his own office.

Whilst I'm all for Free Software and Linux and KDE, there are many times when I prefer to use MS Windows. It's easier. It comes with all the right drivers for my hardware, it doesn't need tweeking to get it "just right". IE renders all the web pages "just right", which Firefox, Opera and Konqueror just don't even get close to. I'm sorry, but they just don't.

I just want to be a user, like the majority of users. I can pay dollars for the proprietory stuff, or I can pay with my dignity when I face the "friendly and helpful [NOT] community".

If Free Software developers are doing the thing to satisfy their own personnal desire for success, well and good. But if they are doing the thing to satisfy the greater good and provide users with useful tools that don't have to be modified or tweeked, or whatever, then they need to pull their heads out of the sand and check out the real users. Just go out on the street and ask a thousand people what they like about developing Free Software, and 999 probably won't even know what you're talking about.

Infotech News
Clicktable.com : Cloud Based Software For Restaurants To Streamline Front Desk Operations
FDI Policy to be simplified further
Hank Summy Joins LiquidHub As Partner, Vertical Markets Lead
Square Yards To Conduct India Wide Training For Real Estate Brokers And Agents
Amazon & Flipkart sale to take place on same dates
Most popular



Kyulux Inc., Corning, Pixelligent, And More Headline OLEDs 2015 Agenda
Android 6.0 Marshmallow: 7 new features
Panasonic Upgrades Video Management Software Suites To Deliver A Full 4K End-To-End Solution
OpenShot 2.0 Open-Source Video Editor To Be Launched Soon
Flipkart gears up to make its BBDay's sale hassle-free
Asus joins the “Make in India” initiative
9 Motorola Phones That Will Get Taste Of Android 6.0
5 Reasons That Suggest Google Is Becoming New Microsoft
LG Watch Urbane 2nd Edition: The First Android Wear Smartwatch With Cellular Support
Arup Employs Highly Innovative Engineering Methodologies For Samsung's Device Solutions America Headquarters
5 things to keep in mind while buying second-hand phones
Intex plans to open fifth manufacturing unit
Praxis Media Private Limited Announces Winners Of The National Dental Achievers, 2015
Top 5 New Features In OS X El Capitan
Must know: Top 5 tech skills for you
Mindteck Chooses AuthShield Multifactor Authentication For Authentication Security


5 Things You Probably Didn't Know About Nexus 5X & 6P
Google's latest Nexus devices are manufactured by LG and Huawei....
Gmail Vs Outlook.com, Which One Is Better?
Gmail offers best features while, Outlook has most user-friendly and clean interface....
Top 5 New Features In OS X El Capitan
El Capitan is a upgrade worth having for Mac users....
9 Motorola Phones That Will Get Taste Of Android 6.0
Motorola is the first manufacturer to announce it’s plans for Marshmallow update....
5 Reasons That Suggest Google Is Becoming New Microsoft
In today's market, Google is under siege from all directions....
5 Ways Microsoft Office 2016 Can Make Your Life Easier
Microsoft Office 2016 is a comprehensive solution that is designed to make your work life easier....
5 Ways To Speed Up Your Mac
Sluggish computing experience is frustrating. Here are 5 ways to help you speed up your Macintosh computer....
5 Tips To Boost Your Home WiFi
You can get the most out of your home WiFi by using simple tricks....
5 Unique Features Of Microsoft Office 2016
Office 2016 brings tons of new features and apps to boost productivity of users....
Top 5 Heroes Of The Linux World
The world of open source is driven by key people who control it....
Top 5 Open Source Software Foundations
Open Source projects are supported and promoted by Open Source Software Foundations. ...
Top 6 Plugins And Extensions For Gmail
These Gmail extensions can boost your email productivity....
6 Hidden Design Features In Apple Products
Apple is known for paying keen attention to design aspects of Apple products. ...
5 Technologies That Tick Off Linus Torvalds
Linux creator is known for making harsh comments on technologies that don't appeal to him!...
Top 5 Open Source Storage Solutions
The right storage solution is crucial for business. Open source tools can minimize the investment cost....
  View All
Meet Pranjal Saxena, India's 21 Year Old Electronics Wizard
Milan Ondhia of EFYTimes was in a forthright conversation with the 21 year old Pranjal Saxena from New Delhi; an aspirant at the WorldSkills meet, in ...
“We Offer Managed Document Solutions To CIO And IT Decision Makers”: Canon
Manufacturing within the country will surely reduce the cost of our devices, but manufacturing can begin only if there is the desired eco-system and w...
“One Day The End User Can Open Up A Used Battery, And Use What’s Inside As Barbecue Sauce”
Of course that is not something currently possible, but what B&B Batteries does have are some secret recipes for their very specialised battery design...
We Wish To Procure All The LED Components Within India: Avni Energy
G. Gururaja, director, Avni Energy Solutions Pvt Ltd, shares his views about the expanding LED industry in the Indian market and the company's plans i...
We Have Registered 50 Per Cent Growth In The Last Two Years: Arihant Lighting
Apart from LEDs, Arihant is associated with the promotion of renewable energy in India and therefore, manufactures various energy saving products....
  View All
First Look: LG Optimus G
The phone sports a high-end display and comes powered by a powerful processor. ...
Create QR-Codes For Free
TEC-IT releases the freeware QR-Code Studio to provide a quick and convenient way of QR code creation for every application scenario....
DoT Secretary Shares Plans For Growth Of Telecom Sector
M.F. Farooqui has recently taken charge as secretary, Department of Telecom....
Hands-On: Sony Xperia Z
Xperia Z is Sony's first entrant model in the big-screen smartphone category. ...
Hands On: Videocon A30 Smartphone
Videocon, the consumer electronics company which is known for its refrigerators, washing machine and air-conditioner has unveiled its Android-based sm...
View All
IFA 2014
IFA 2014: LG Launches 34-Inches Curved Monitor
The company is yet to confirm price and availability of the device....
IFA 2014: Intel Launches First Core M Range Of Processors
This range of processors is tailor-made for 2-in-1 devices which include a tablet and a laptop....
MWC 2014: Tablet Lets People Feel Textures On Its Screen
Now feel what you see on your tablet, by way of ultrasonic waves....
MWC 2014: 4K Android Tablet Games To Kill Consoles, iPad
Tablet makers like Samsung want to beat the iPad by making 4K tabs. ...
MWC 2014: This Vodafone Backpack Helps Get Network In Disaster Situations
Two engineers of Vodafone New Zealand displayed the "mini" mobile network by Vodafone substructure in a backpack. ...
MWC 2014: Wilocity Chipset To Bring 'Lightening' Speed To Mobile Phones
Wilocity has developed a WiGig chipset for mobile phones that will bring lightning-fast wireless capability ...
MWC 2014: Samsung Introduces Octacore, Hexacore Chipsets
The Korean giant, Samsung unveiled two new octacore and hexacore chipsets at MWC 2014, in Barcelona. The company previously used Exynos 5 Octa 5410 ch...
View All
19th Consumer Electronic Imaging Fair To Be Held On ...

View All

home archives contact us advertise with us
Magazines Portals Directories Events News Verticals Educational Institute  
Electronics for You
Open Source for You
Electronics Bazaar
Electronics Annual Guide
EFY Awards
Linux & Open Source
Consumer Electronics
Science & Technology
EFY Techcenter

Educational Kits
© Copyright 2015 EFY Enterprises Pvt. Ltd.
All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without written permission is prohibited.
Usage of the content from the web site is subject to Terms and Conditions