EFY Times  
Thursday, December 18, 2014

 
GO
 
 

Richard M. Stallman Responds To Linus Torvalds' Blog
 
Home >> Infotech >> Interviews
 
Richard M. Stallman Responds To Linus Torvalds' Blog  
 
While Linus Torvalds reportedly accuses Richard M. Stallman for being a one-issue man, RMS clears the air in this face-to-face interview. He discusses much more than that. Read on...   
Rate this news:  (11 Votes)
Saturday, January 31, 2009 It was one of the rarest opportunities to spend some time with the man I’ve always looked up to since I migrated to GNU/Linux systems. The father of the free software movement, Richard M. Stallman was in Delhi for three days, and during the time I spent with RMS, we discussed various topics that helped me get to the bottom of why ‘Free Software’ matters so much. This frank discussion with RMS also covers topics like the entire confusion created around patents and copyright, what a sensible government should do, why free software matters for an enterprise as well as a developer and what will happen to the free software movement after RMS… though we wish him to live another 100 years. Here is what RMS has to say in response to Linus Torvalds' blog along with much more.

INTERVIEW,RMS




Swapnil:Linus Torvalds recently criticised you on his blog at torvalds-family.blogspot.com/2008/11/black-and-white.html. Do you have something to say about that?
RMS:Well, you can see that he is a person who doesn’t believe in freedom. You can tell that from his writings. Why does he reject GPLv3, because GPL3 protects users from tivoization, which is a fairly new method of denying freedom. It did not exist when I wrote GPLv2 or I would have done something about it then.

Tivoization means delivering a product with some free software, but the machines are designed so that if the user installs a modified version, it won’t run at all. So theoretically, the users are free to study and change the source code, but they can’t run their own binaries. This means that if they change the source code, it’s useless. So practically, they don’t have the freedom to study and change the program. Therefore, I decided in GPLv3 to prevent this. V3 requires the manufacturer to provide to the user the information necessary for the user to install his own changed binaries in the product he owns and make it run, assuming it is possible—if it’s denied by law, then it’s okay, because no one can change that.

We are trying to stop a practice where a manufacturer can change it, but the user can’t. Well, this is what Torvalds objects to. He is in favour of tivoization. He doesn’t care if the user of, in this case Linux, is free to change it. So, what can we do? He has a right to his views. I am not a one-issue person and I care about a lot of political issues, as you can see if you look at stallman.org. But the free software movement is a one-issue movement. Lots of people support the free software movement, who have different views on other issues. That’s why I put my views on other issues into my personal site—they are not part of the free software movement.


In addition to this chilly pepper question, there were many like "what free software is all about, according to you?" He replied to that question in detail which lead to many other questions which you can check in LINUX For You magazine, February 2009 issue or wait for a while for them to appear online. It was also important to ask him, "To whom does free software matter?" and that "Is there any particular reason why free software makes more sense in a country like India?".

There is another confusion around using patent, copyright, trademark etc. in the same context. Then there is something called "intellectual property". People have been misusing these terms a lot. RMS clears the confusion:

Swapnil:Can you clarify a bit between copyright and patents?
RMS:First thing, copyright and patents have nothing to do with each other. So, you may as well ask me to clarify between copyright and trees… or side walks.

Swapnil:But at times, people do try to club them together...
RMS:The first thing to realise is that copyright and patents have nothing in common; they are totally unrelated laws. What one of them does, the other one doesn’t. So, in particular, if someone starts making statements using ‘intellectual property’, that is a sign of confusion, because that term attempts to generalise several different laws (copyright is one of them), when all these laws have nothing in common.

So, whatever that person says is pure confusion; it is nonsense. And this nonsense is being passed off as meaningful. But, most people don’t know it is nonsense, so they repeat the nonsense. There are also people who know how wrong it is, but they use it and then they justify it. There are a lot of others who are simply trying to mislead other people. It is in their interest not to have other people understand these issues.


Swapnil:Is there any connection between the two at all?
RMS: What has copyright to do with licencing and what does it have to do with free software? Well, under today’s copyright law, any work that is written or composed somehow is automatically copyrighted. So, there is a copyright on that work or particular authorship. By default, the copyright law says that people are not allowed to copy or distribute or modify the program. In some countries people are not allowed to run it without permission. So, how do you make free software?

The only way is through a formal declaration by the copyright holder saying that you, the user, have the four freedoms. That declaration, we call the free software licence. It is not the only context in which the term ‘licence’ is used. Licences are signed contracts, but this one is not. This is simply a unilateral grant of permission from the copyright holders of the program. Free software licences have some conditions. It could be a tiny requirement like you can’t remove this licence, but some other licences have more requirements. For example, I wrote a licence, which is one of the many free software licences, called the GNU General Public Licence or GNU GPL. And it is used in over two-thirds of all the free software packages. However, GPL is not all—there are other free software licences too.

What’s special about this licence is there are certain requirements we call copy-left and that is: “When you redistribute copies of the program, either exact or modified, you must keep the licence the same and you must distribute the whole of the modified version under the same licence and make the source code available.” These licences make an extra effort to defend the freedom of every user.


But these are only few of the questions that I asked him -- there are many more. The full interview has been published in LINUX For You magazine, February 2009 issue. You can get a copy of the magazine from the stand and read the complete interview. EFYTimes will publish the full text of the interview in a couple of weeks.

Swapnil Bhartiya, EFYTIMES News Network


Print Email Post Comment  (2)
(Total Views: 34248)
 
Share

 
 

2 Comments

Jinny   2146 days ago

RMS and Linus both are my heros -- RMS is a prophet and Linus and engineer. I wish if these two FORCES of freedom come together, even majors like Microsoft will bend on their knees, please Linus get along with RMS please please please...Hey friends, do you also feel the same?
Reply   1 Reply
Prof B N Kshirsagar   2124 days ago

I do agree with your proposal of becoming a group of RMS and Linus to promote Free and Open world.
Reply  
 
Infotech News
   
SAP India Wins The I.C.O.N.I.C IDC Insights Award For Excellence In Innovation In Telecom, Media And Technology Vertical
Chennai-Based Hetrogenous And Technrwheels Collaborate To Offer Compelling Solution For Taxi Service Dispatch And Customer Safety
IIT Bombay Launches A Two-Part Course On Signals And Systems On The EdX Platform
Zenga Strikes Gold Again; Brings Home Two Honors At One Go
MetricStream Partners With ECC International To Help Companies In The Philippines Enhance Compliance, Risk, And Audit Management
 
 
 
     
     
     
     
     
     
Most popular
 

Daily

Weekly

Top 8 Open Source Machine Learning Tools
5 Myths And Mistakes Coding Job Seekers Do!
IITs, IIMs Will Now Offer Online Courses!
5 Tech Skills That Are Getting Outdated!
Lenovo Tab S8 With Single SIM And 4G LTE Support Launched
Acer Launches Liquid Jade S Smartphone With 64-Bit Octa-Core SoC
YouTube App To Support Offline Viewing In India
TCS May Give Pink Slips To Its Employees
CA Technologies Helps Customers Stimulate App User Loyalty With APM Solution Designed For Simplicity, Mobility And DevOps Velocity
Top 10 Incredible But Not-So-Famous Google Tools
Micromax Canvas Selfie Arrives With 13-MP Front And Rear Cameras
5 Must-Know Basic Electronics Skills!
Soon, Trains Will Have Laser System Installed To Remove Debris From Tracks!
Snappy Ubuntu Ensures Docker Container Security
Xiaomi Cannot Import, Sell Handsets In India: Delhi HC
Want To Learn Programming Faster? Try These Project Ideas!
 
   

Overall

Features
Debian Vs Ubuntu: Here Are The Changes Made In Last 10 Years!
Find out the historical differences made in both Linux systems over the period of past 10 years....
These Linux Desktops Have Better UI and UX As Compared To Windows And Mac!
When people think about Linux, they picture the old desktop PC with command line but, this picture has changed over the years....
Top 8 MySQL GUI Tools
This useful list of MySQL GUI tools can help you with your database management....
5 Must-Know Basic Electronics Skills!
These video tutorials can help you learn important DIY electronic skills!...
5 Myths And Mistakes Coding Job Seekers Do!
Here are the 5 mistakes and 5 myths that coding job hunters often end up doing!...
5 Misconceptions About Git That Developers Have!
The popular and flexible VCS platform Git is still criticized by few developers, courtesy the misconceptions!...
6 Useful Tips For First-Time Web App Developers!
Developing your first web app? This guide will help you to work smart....
Top 8 Open Source Applications And Projects Of 2014
Here is the list of top 8 cool open-source apps of the year....
7 Stages Of Drupal Learning Curve!
Drupal is hard, but Drupal is awesome! You can learn Drupal after crossing seven certain stages....
Top 12 ASP .NET based CMS Platforms
Building a website using CMS platform is easy if you are using the right CMS for your needs....
Top 10 Fastest Supercomputers In The World!
Ever wondered what would be the speed of world's fastest super computers? Here is the treat!...
Learn How To Get A Job As A Computer Security Analyst!
The word analyst doesn’t necessarily mean a boring job, in fact, it is very interesting. ...
8 Tools To Boost Productivity Of Content Creators!
These tools for bloggers, content writers or other content marketing professionals are designed to save tons of time and efforts....
8 Proposed Improvements In Java 9 Which Look Promising!
Here are eight proposals which have been made for JDK 9 developers....
Learn How To Create Virtual Machines With Us!
This guide will help you in setting up and using a virtual machine on your computer....
 
  View All
Dialogue
 
10 Questions That Google Never Asks While Hiring!
Here is a list of 10 questions that Google just banned from their interviews....
For Enjay, Open Source Technology Is A Way Of Life
An entirely open source-based company, Enjay IT Solutions, has built itself a reputation in the OSS domain....
Switching To Tizen Doesn’t Mean We Are Abandoning Android: Samsung
The company has worked to build Tizen up from scratch and has now introduced it to developers and the general public with its latest range of wearable...
Venturing Into The Cloud? Develop A Customised Cloud Strategy First!
Diksha P Gupta speaks to Rushikesh Jadhav, cloud evangelist, ESDS Software Solution Pvt Ltd, on how the cloud has changed the way compan...
HTC Is Strong And There Are No Plans Of Sale Now Or In Future, Says HTC's Senior Director-Marketing
Atithya Amaresh from EFYTimes had an exclusive chat with Sirpa H. Ikola, senior director, Marketing, South Asia, HTC about its devices and its plans w...
   
  View All
Videos
 
First Look: LG Optimus G
The phone sports a high-end display and comes powered by a powerful processor. ...
Create QR-Codes For Free
TEC-IT releases the freeware QR-Code Studio to provide a quick and convenient way of QR code creation for every application scenario....
DoT Secretary Shares Plans For Growth Of Telecom Sector
M.F. Farooqui has recently taken charge as secretary, Department of Telecom....
Hands-On: Sony Xperia Z
Xperia Z is Sony's first entrant model in the big-screen smartphone category. ...
Hands On: Videocon A30 Smartphone
Videocon, the consumer electronics company which is known for its refrigerators, washing machine and air-conditioner has unveiled its Android-based sm...
   
View All
   
 
IFA 2014
 
IFA 2014: LG Launches 34-Inches Curved Monitor
The company is yet to confirm price and availability of the device....
IFA 2014: Intel Launches First Core M Range Of Processors
This range of processors is tailor-made for 2-in-1 devices which include a tablet and a laptop....
MWC 2014: Tablet Lets People Feel Textures On Its Screen
Now feel what you see on your tablet, by way of ultrasonic waves....
MWC 2014: 4K Android Tablet Games To Kill Consoles, iPad
Tablet makers like Samsung want to beat the iPad by making 4K tabs. ...
MWC 2014: This Vodafone Backpack Helps Get Network In Disaster Situations
Two engineers of Vodafone New Zealand displayed the "mini" mobile network by Vodafone substructure in a backpack. ...
MWC 2014: Wilocity Chipset To Bring 'Lightening' Speed To Mobile Phones
Wilocity has developed a WiGig chipset for mobile phones that will bring lightning-fast wireless capability ...
MWC 2014: Samsung Introduces Octacore, Hexacore Chipsets
The Korean giant, Samsung unveiled two new octacore and hexacore chipsets at MWC 2014, in Barcelona. The company previously used Exynos 5 Octa 5410 ch...
   
View All
   
 
Events
 
19th Consumer Electronic Imaging Fair To Be Held On ...

View All
   
   
 
 

home archives contact us advertise with us
           
Magazines Portals Directories Events News Verticals Educational Institute  
Electronics for You
Open Source for You
Electronics Bazaar
electronicsforu.com
efytimes.com
opensourceforu.com
electronicsb2b.com
Electronics Annual Guide
EFY EXPO INDIA
EFY EXPO WEST
ELECTRONICS ROCKS
EFY Awards
OSIDAYS Expo
Electronics
Infotech
Linux & Open Source
Consumer Electronics
Science & Technology
BPO
EFY Techcenter

Educational Kits
Kitsnspares.com  
 
 
© Copyright 2014 EFY Enterprises Pvt. Ltd.
All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without written permission is prohibited.
Usage of the content from the web site is subject to Terms and Conditions